FILM REVIEW – The Woman In Black

By Marty Mulrooney

The Woman In Black

The Woman In Black is a horror film directed by James Watkins, based on the classic Susan Hill novel of the same name. Set during the Edwardian era, it is produced by Hammer Film Productions and stars Daniel Radcliffe as Arthur Kipps, a young solicitor who is sent to the English coast to attend to the estate of a woman named Alice Drablow who has recently died. Once there, he must travel to Eel Marsh House, located near dense marshes and cut off from the mainland during high tide. Attending to paperwork, he captures glimpses of a mysterious woman in black. The locals in the nearby town seem frightened and their children even more so. What could possibly have the power to terrify so greatly? Soon, Arthur Kipps will find out…

The Woman In Black is regarded by many as one of the most chilling ghost stories of all time – the 1983 novel possesses a timeless quality that still has the power to scare to this very day. The stage play adaptation (reviewed on AMO here)  has been running since 1987, continually thrilling critics and audiences alike. ITV also aired a television version in 1989 that was nominated for four BAFTA awards. This new film adaptation takes the book as its inspiration (the stage play made several notable additions to the story), but by no means is this a straight-up retelling.  Jane Goldman’s script makes several changes to a familiar tale, some welcome, others less so.

Daniel Radcliffe, fresh from filming the final Harry Potter film, makes a pleasing Kipps, though he does appear slightly too young to be the father of a four-year-old boy. Nonetheless, he looks the part and plays it well. The plot point of a son who needs supporting after his mother’s death also gives incentive for Kipps to not only make the journey to Eel Marsh House, but keep returning despite the ghostly apparitions he witnesses. Everyone acts their parts well, although some of the supporting cast can seem slightly hammy at times in their depictions of regular folk who live their lives in fear of something they don’t fully understand.

The main problem is that the original story, rich in detail, is told in a perfunctory manner. There are scary moments aplenty, good old-fashioned scares that don’t need to rely on gore. The special effects are subtle and Eel Marsh House itself is a master of both sound and visual design. Yet authentic relationships between the characters are largely absent. Being alone in Eel Marsh House is a terrifying thought – in both the book and play, the company of a dog or a fellow human being offers welcome respite from this fear, however momentary and fleeting. The dog still makes an appearance and Ciarán Hinds as wealthy landowner Sam Daily is likeable enough, but the opportunity to show Kipps truly bonding with these characters is ultimately missed.

Instead, the film relies on the concept of a haunted house brought to life. Doors lock themselves, chairs rock back and forth and candles blow out. Creepy children’s toys stare with dull eyes, screaming inwardly as their mechanical insides whir tinkling lullabies of death. The woman in black is most terrifying when she simply appears in the frame, watching. Waiting. When the filmmakers have her float towards Daniel Radcliffe, open mouthed and screaming, they get a reaction, but it’s cheap. Isn’t causing the death of innocent children horrifying enough? Hammer Film Productions reportedly shaved 6 seconds of footage from The Woman In Black to lower the rating from a 15 to a 12A in the UK. This move is very telling – there is no doubt a better film lurking, much like the woman in black, within this production. It caters too much to the mainstream and makes concessions for the easily pleased, but when it works, it’s eerie and effective.

The Woman In Black, despite the negatives expressed in this review, is not a bad film at all. Visually, it captures the source material extremely well and there are several moments that successfully bring the spirit of the book to life. Daniel Radcliffe proves that there is more to his acting than just Harry Potter, and the new ending is surprisingly effective, able to be viewed in several different ways. Its a good film, but it could have done with more mystery and uncertainty to it. This is a motion picture that deals predominantly with death – in the end, it just needed a little bit more life.

7.5 OUT OF 10

STAGE REVIEW – The Woman In Black, The Lowry Theatre, 22/01/2010


Filed under Film

4 responses to “FILM REVIEW – The Woman In Black

  1. So I finally got around to seeing this last weekend. I think 7.5 is a tad generous, but overall this was a great review and I agree with almost all your points, as usual! The film oozes atmosphere and I absolutely loved the “feel” of it; high marks there. I really wish horror filmmakers didn’t feel the need to resort to such cheap and obvious effects; it ruins everything when they give too much away. I appreciated many things about this remake, but I don’t think I can recommend it nearly enough as the original, which despite its age and comparatively minuscule budget, is the superior film.

    • Thanks for commenting shezcrafti, always a pleasure to read your thoughts. The original film passed me by sadly, although I did check it out on YouTube whilst writing this review and thought it seemed really creepy! However for me, nothing can beat the stage play – it’s amazing how two men on a stage with minimal props managed to grip me far more than this fairly big-budget screen adaptation.

  2. I liked this film, mostly because of its subtle ghostly activity and eerie setting but also because it revisited the Hammer Films of yesteryear as a period piece. Great review, I wonder if any of the stage play is on Youtube?

  3. Lizbeth

    I’m looking for an older version of this film, it was black and white and I watched it about 23 years ago. It was about a ghost who killed children, but I can’t find anything on it, only a television show. However I thought the remake although slow to start was brilliant. It has a great story, and relies on atmosphere to build up to the point where we actually see her.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.